Art and psychology have always overlapped. Artists show inner states; psychologists try to explain them. One of the places they meet most clearly is the uncanny: the feeling you get from something that looks familiar but is slightly wrong. A human shape with one eye too many. A calm room where the shadows point the wrong way. That small wrongness makes you look twice, and while you are looking, you start to recognise something about yourself.
What “the uncanny” means
Sigmund Freud wrote an essay on the uncanny in 1919, describing the unsettling feeling when the familiar turns strange. Since then the idea has shaped horror films, surrealist painting and even robot design. In illustration it doesn’t need to be scary. A gentle uncanny image can feel tender, sad or funny.
Why the uncanny helps recognition
- It slows the viewer down. A slightly odd detail stops the scroll.
- It mirrors odd inner states. Dissociation, anxiety and grief often make ordinary life feel strange. An uncanny image matches that.
- It avoids cliché. Familiar symbols get skipped. Strange ones get read.
How I use it
My figures are human-shaped but simplified: long necks, flat faces, a brain drawn as a pattern, a head growing branches. The compositions are calm and often symmetrical, so the strangeness never becomes chaos. That balance of order and oddness is what I’m after. It lets viewers stay with a difficult feeling without being pushed away. I’ve written about the structure side in Symmetry in Trauma Art and the vocabulary side in The Alien Dictionary.
Practical uses
For a therapy practice or mental health publisher, a gently uncanny image can open a conversation that a stock photo would close. It says: this is about the inside, not the outside. For brands, it makes visuals memorable without shock tactics.
Tips if you want to try it
- Start with something ordinary: a face, a chair, a window.
- Change one thing: size, number, direction or material.
- Keep everything else calm and simple so the change stands out.
- Ask what feeling the change creates, and adjust until it matches the one you mean.
The uncanny versus the uncanny valley
People often mix up the uncanny with the uncanny valley. The uncanny valley describes the discomfort we feel when a robot or digital human looks almost, but not quite, real. It usually pushes people away.
The kind of uncanny I use works differently. My figures are clearly drawn and stylised, so nobody mistakes them for real people. The strangeness comes from meaning, not from realism gone slightly wrong. A head with branches growing out of it isn’t creepy; it’s a way of showing thoughts that keep spreading. That keeps the viewer curious instead of uneasy.
This distinction matters for anyone commissioning art about mental health. You want images that hold attention and invite reflection, not images that repel. Stylisation, soft colour and calm composition keep the uncanny on the right side of that line.
It also explains why heavily realistic AI images often feel cold for this kind of content. They aim for realism and miss meaning. A simple drawn metaphor does the opposite.
Frequently asked questions
Is uncanny art the same as dark art?
No. Uncanny art can be soft and even playful. The key is the mix of familiar and strange, not darkness.
Can uncanny images work for wellness brands?
Yes, when the tone is gentle. They help content feel thoughtful rather than generic.
See examples in my portfolio or contact me about a project.
Wish You a Purple Day!